The vampires re-captured Alex, but she was rescued by Jody and the Winchesters.
After being taken in by Jody Mills, Annie continued using the name Alex.
At dinner, Alex tells the Winchesters that the weird things Claire has been hunting have been based off of a crime blog, prompting the annoyed Claire to reveal that Alex and Henry plan to sneak off to Jody's cabin to have sex, prompting Jody to give Alex a highly awkward sex talk.
While talking to Dean, Jody tells him that things were rough with Alex for awhile, but she'd started to turn things around, even dating the most popular guy in school.
That night, after Jody informs her that her grandmother, all that was left of her human family, was dead, her vampire "family" arrives and kidnaps her, knocking Jody out.
At the nest, Annie is surprised to learn that Celia forgives her even though her actions led to the deaths of Cody and Dale.
After getting a breaking-and-entering call, Frank leaves her alone and her vampire "brother" Cody arrives, having hunted her down.School gets cancelled as a result and Alex leaves with Henry and they walk along a stream. Phelps' death as he'd believed in her and because of the way he died. Alex admits she wasn't always the good person she is now and has done awful things in the past, remembering the terrible things she did while with Celia and her family of vampires.Henry reassures her that he doesn't care about her past and they kiss.As they leave, Jody notices birth control pills in Alex's bag.Returning home, Jody and Alex are surprised to find the Winchesters there, having been called in by Claire, to Jody and Alex's annoyance, as neither of them believes there's a monster around.Jody later calls Alex again, where it would appear that Alex is in the middle of raucous party.She hangs up on Jody after Jody asks why she is hearing fireworks.As Alex leaves school with her boyfriend Henry, one of her friends approaches her, having heard that she and Henry are in the lead for Prom Queen and King. Phelps walks by and reminds Alex about a test she has the next day.Alex is then picked up by Jody, who tells her she is proud of her for fitting into a normal life.In 2015, Claire Novak also moved in with Jody Mills, following the death of her mother.She and Alex developed a slightly fractious sibling relationship, with Alex trying to live a normal life and Claire determined to become a hunter in her own right.Jody admits she was trying to do the same with her own dead family and Annie and Celia go to kill her.However, Annie injects Celia with Jody's dead man's blood, saving Jody to the shock and anger of Celia.Celia knocks out Jody and tries to get Annie to feed on her, but Annie tries to spare Jody as she was so nice to her.